A GoCheckMy site
GoCheckMySports The score is a fact. The story gets checked.
Vol. I · No. 43

GoCheckMy Sports

The Result, and How It Happened.

The Desk

Michigan 13, Western Michigan 12, September 5: Hail Mary on Restored Second Ends Upset Bid

Bryce Underwood connected with JJ Buchanan on a Hail Mary as time expired to give Michigan a 13-12 victory over Western Michigan on September 5, but officials' decision to restore one second to the clock after reviewing the previous play has drawn immediate scrutiny from media analysts and the MAC commissioner.

Michigan and Western Michigan were tied at 12 apiece late on September 5 when Bryce Underwood attempted a Hail Mary for JJ Buchanan with time expiring. The ball fell incomplete as the clock hit 0:00, and Western Michigan had survived a 27.5-point upset bid as a 27.5-point underdog. Then officials reviewed the previous play, put one second back on the clock, and allowed Michigan a final snap. On that second attempt, Underwood found Buchanan amid Western Michigan defenders in the end zone. Michigan won 13-12, giving Kyle Whittingham a dramatic victory in his debut as head coach.

The clock restoration stands at the center of immediate controversy. NBC rules analyst Terry McAulay said on air that no explanation was given for why a second was restored when both the game clock and NBC's broadcast clock read 0:00 before the ball reached a player. Multiple media figures questioned the decision within hours: Pete Thamel noted the extra second would be "the most scrutinized second in college football this weekend"; Dan Wolken called it "a major college football scandal" and called for "investigations and firings"; Stewart Mandel stated the conference would need to explain why a second was restored; Chris Vannini said all replays showed 0 seconds; Chris Fallica called it "total robbery."

Michigan's offense had limped to the finish. According to CBS Sports, Underwood's footwork and timing were inconsistent, causing him to miss several routine throws. The run game was a non-factor for most of the night and the offensive line failed to get a push up front despite a major talent advantage, per CBS Sports. An ill-timed throw to the sideline late in the second quarter resulted in a turnover that was nearly returned for a touchdown by Western Michigan's Dillon Moore, according to CBS Sports reporting.

Continued →

The Evening Brief The desk's synthesis · 11:17 PM UTC

The day's thread is resilience under pressure. Baseball produced four walk-off wins across the Cleveland Guardians organization on September 4, with three coming within minutes of each other in doubleheader nightcaps. The Cubs hit their 200th home run of the season, the first team in 2026 to reach that mark, and defeated Miami 6-5 on September 6 with reliever Ryan Zeferjahn recording his first save after a rocky start with his new team. Riley Greene, back from a hamstring strain that sidelined Detroit for a month and left the Tigers at 4-14, went 4-for-4 with two home runs to shut out Cleveland 6-0. These were not anomalies but examples of what September demands: finishing close games and converting chances when they appear.

That theme carried into tennis, where the US Open's fourth round on September 6 featured five American men, the strongest male contingent at a Grand Slam since 1995, and ten American players total in the round of 16. Defending champion Carlos Alcaraz, returning from a four-and-a-half-month wrist injury, dropped only one set in four matches and defeated Tommy Paul 6-4, 6-3, 6-4 to reach the quarterfinals. On September 5, Zheng Qinwen, ranked No. 121 and competing as a qualifier after elbow surgery, rallied from a set down and a 5-0 third-set deficit, with Keys holding match point, to defeat No. 22 seed Madison Keys and reach the fourth round. Anastasia Potapova upset No. 10 seed Amanda Anisimova 6-2, 7-5 on the same day. These finishes were built on refusing to yield.

In international motorsports, Kimi Antonelli won the Italian Grand Prix on September 6 from 19th on the grid after an engine penalty, the second-deepest grid-to-win comeback in Formula 1 history. His 66-point championship lead remains material, but his ability to overcome penalties and still win outright underscores how narrow a buffer can be when circumstances align against it.

College football and officiating diverged sharply from this resilience narrative. The NBC broadcast clock showed 0:00 when the initial pass fell incomplete; the Big Ten's replay system determined one second remained on the clock. The Big Ten cited a strobe-sync protocol, suggesting the replay camera and broadcast camera were misaligned. NBC rules analyst Terry McAulay questioned this explanation on air, noting the ball was not close to a player when the broadcast clock reached zero. Western Michigan president Russ Kavalhuna requested a formal review. The MAC commissioner contacted the Big Ten about the decision. The gap between what television showed and what replay officials announced remains unexplained in the Big Ten's public statement, leaving the foundation of the call unclear and the finish as the day's most contested moment.

In boxing, Katie Taylor retired as an undisputed light-welterweight champion after defeating Flora Pili on points (100-90, 100-90, 98-91) at Croke Park in Dublin on September 5. The 40-year-old closed her 27-fight professional career with 26 wins and no defeats as a professional, choosing her venue and her moment.

In college football, Clemson absorbed a 51-10 loss to LSU on September 6 in Lane Kiffin's debut, the worst defeat in Dabo Swinney's tenure. Clemson managed 40 rushing yards, eight first downs, and a quarterback change by halftime. Swinney's hiring of offensive coordinator Chad Morris and his decision to decline transfer quarterback options in the portal cycle shaped the roster construction that produced the result. The performance has reignited questions about Swinney's future, though his $57 million buyout obligation remains a constraint on any athletic department decision.

In the Cardinals-Rockies series, home-plate umpire Doug Eddings instructed rookie Hancel Rincon to straighten his tilted cap during his MLB debut on September 5, leading to manager Oliver Marmol's ejection when he defended the pitcher. Eddings told reporters he did not know if it was an official rule but called it an unwritten one. On September 6, Cardinals players and a few Rockies wore their hats off-center in the dugout in silent protest. MLB Rule 3.03(g) and (h) cover potential distractions but do not address hat angles specifically.

Red Sox placed All-Star center fielder Ceddanne Rafaela on the 10-day injured list on September 6 with a right quadriceps strain, retroactive to September 4, making him eligible to return September 13.

Vikings re-signed safety Harrison Smith on a one-year deal worth $12.25 million with incentives to $16.25 million for his 15th season after designated replacement Jamal Adams tore his knee in the preseason.

Back issues: 2026-09-14 · 2026-09-13 · 2026-09-12 · 2026-09-11 · 2026-09-10 · 2026-09-09 · 2026-09-08 · 2026-09-07 · 2026-09-05 · 2026-09-04 · 2026-09-03 · 2026-09-02 · 2026-09-01
GoCheckMy Sports is a news desk of Go Check My Brands LLC · Every source linked · Never betting advice Standards & Corrections · Archive